Record low charity mergers

The full charity Good Merger Index report can be downloaded here:

Social sector consultancy Eastside People has launched the 10th edition of the Good Merger Index (2022/23), the review of merger data across the charitable sector in England and Wales. While demand for charities’ services is growing at an ever-increasing rate, many face existential threats due to rising costs, falling funding and deceasing donations. In addition, ahead of the Spring Budget in March, charities have asked the Chancellor for additional support to protect the immediate and longer-term financial health of the sector.

Over the last 12 months, Eastside People has seen a 70% rise in the number of enquiries from charity leaders looking for expertise in managing and delivering merger and partnership projects. Despite all this activity, however, the GMI research found that there were only 48 successful mergers between 96 organisations during 2022/23, 6% fewer than the previous year and 37% down on 2020/21, the lowest number since the GMI started with the year 2013-14 and a tiny proportion of the total industry¹.

Mergers, in most cases, do not happen quickly. Decisions taken to merge may be made a year or more before completion (before 2022 for some of the charities covered by our research), at a time when the sector was still feeling the impact of the Covid pandemic but protected in part by furlough monies and emergency government and charity grant funding..

Merger data from 2022/23 provides the facts, but we are 12-18 months further on from the circumstances and decisions that will have started those merger discussions. Indications are that conditions today are worse for both society and the sector with many not-for-profit organisations sadly being forced to close their doors for good when a strategic approach to merger or long-term partnership may have been an alternative solution.

“Despite these findings, Eastside People has seen a 70% increase in enquiries and a 30% increase in merger related projects in the last 12 months. Success stories such as those from Keech Hospice Care, Rennie Grove Peace Hospice Care and Kisharon Langdon show that mergers are an option to consider and can enhance the services and support that their beneficiaries need.” said Cara Evans, Head of Partnerships and Mergers at Eastside People.

Key Stats (Financial data is from the year prior to merger and which were completed by 30^th April 2023):

• The number of mergers recorded (48) and the total number of organisations involved (96) is the lowest since we started the Good Merger Index with the year 2013-14
• Approximately £32m of income was collectively transferred from one charity to another which is 78% lower than the average over 10 years of £146m
• As a whole, the data illustrates that the total number of mergers in this period fell by 6% from the previous year and by 37% from 2020-21
• Despite a slight rise in the number of mergers involving smaller organisations, there has been a more significant fall in the number of mergers involving larger organisations – lower than any previous year
• The total income of the organisations involved in mergers was £483 million This is a rise of £17 million from the previous year
• The 20 largest mergers represented £30.9m of income and 98% of the total financial value transferred, significantly lower than the 2021-22 figure of £77.1m
• There were only 4 mergers of equals during 2022-23 (the merger of similar-sized charities)
• The proportion of transferee (receiving organisations) in surplus remained at a more typical level of 64% giving them a more suitable position to take on the risk of a merger. This figure is significantly higher than it was in the year 2020-21, which could reasonably be attributed to the impact of the Covid pandemic on charity’s finances.
• Despite these findings, Eastside People has seen a 70% increase in enquiries and a 30% increase in merger related projects in the last year.

The launch of Eastside People’s latest Good Merger Index (GMI) Review took place on Wednesday 7^th February 2024.

Our panel of experts who all had recent experiences of charity mergers, partnerships and closures were:

1. Sir David Holmes CBE, Chief Executive of Family Action and ex Chair of Children England, a charity that sadly closed in December 2023
2. Liz Searle, CEO of Keech Hospice Care that merged with Bedford Daycare Hospice last year
3. Paul Townsley Chief Executive of Humankind Charity supporting people to achieve their goals & make positive changes for better-connected communities which is merging with Richmond Fellowship this year.

Watch the recording of the launch event to hear what the report found and what our panellists had to say.