menu

About Us

Eastside People

Eastside People

Case Studies

Case Studies

What Our Clients Say

What Our Clients Say

News & Insights

News & Insights

Equity, Diversity & Inclusion (EDI)

Equity, Diversity & Inclusion (EDI)

Our Partners

Our Partners

Eastside Primetimers Foundation

Eastside Primetimers Foundation

Contact Us

Contact Us

Consultancy

Consultancy Services

Consultancy Services

Artificial Intelligence (AI) & Digital

Artificial Intelligence (AI) & Digital

Culture & Workforce

Culture & Workforce

Governance

Governance

Impact Measurement & Evaluation Reports

Impact Measurement & Evaluation Reports

Income Generation & Fundraising

Income Generation & Fundraising

Merger & Partnership Consultancy Services

Merger & Partnership Consultancy Services

Social Investment

Social Investment

Strategy

Strategy

Recruitment

Interim Management

Interim Management

Board Recruitment

Board Recruitment

Executive Search

Executive Search

Vacancies

Vacancies

Our People

Our Culture

Our Culture

Our Central Team

Our Central Team

Our Consultants

Our Consultants

Join Us

Join Us

Knowledge Base

News & Insights

News & Insights

Resources

Resources

Events

Events

Free ESG Assessment Tool

Free ESG Assessment Tool

Federated Charity Merger Advice 4 of 5: Our Recommendations

Charity merger recommendations applicable not just to leaders of federated charities but the whole charity sector

Steve Chu Merger Blog – Advice for all charities considering a merger

Steve Chu’s recent Masters dissertation explored the barriers to successful mergers within federated charity networks. It found a lack of previous research into charity mergers, and almost no recent research into federated charities such as Age UK, Mind, RSPCA and Citizens Advice.

This series of five blogs aims to distil his key dissertation findings into short, readable snapshots which are aimed to be of use to all charity leaders considering a merger with another charity. The dissertation formed part of Steve’s MSc in Charity Accounting and Financial Management, from Bayes Business School.

The 5 blogs cover:

  1. Drivers for merger, desired outcomes 
  2. Overcoming barriers to merger success
  3. Mergers and the unique characteristics of federated charity networks
  4. Charity merger recommendations
  5. Wider recommendations for federated charity networks.

The first blog in this series explored the reasons why charities consider merging. But charity mergers are viewed negatively by many, as being “not a thing that charities do”, or even “a dirty word.” Often, Chief Executives or Trustees are blamed for not wanting to give up power and control.

The second blog in the series outlined some barriers to successful charity mergers, and how they may be overcome – these are mostly human factors which may hinder, or help, rational decision-making.

The third blog explores specific factors within federated networks, where the presence of an additional stakeholder, in the shape of a national charity, provides an important additional factor.

Blog 4 of 5: Recommendations for charity mergers

My previous blogs in this series have explored the barriers to charity mergers and how they can be overcome, with additional considerations for federated charity networks. In this fourth blog, I summarise some merger recommendations which are relevant throughout the charity sector.

Focus on your charity’s beneficiary outcomes

Too often, charity leaders can be fixated on the survival of their entity, over and above beneficiary outcomes. By focusing conversations on how best to maximise impact, a merger can be viewed as a strategic tool to achieve more. The Charity Commission could support this approach by reinstating its previous “duty to consider” advice, so that merger discussions can be normalised and viewed as part of an annual strategy-setting conversation, not a “dirty word” only to be uttered in extremis.

Use opportune moments

Advanced knowledge that a Chair or Chief Executive is planning to step down can enable a less emotional review of the full range of future leadership options for the charity, with a key barrier removed. Charities should be encouraged not automatically to think of replacing the leader, but using the forthcoming vacancy as an opportunity to think afresh.

Charity Leader training and development

Some resistance to mergers is that they are viewed as a step into the unknown, whereas the presence of a leader with previous merger experience can help to overcome barriers. The development of specialist charity leader training courses focused on merger considerations and implementation, peer support, and transformational and visionary leadership, could improve leader confidence in responding positively to a potential process.

Additional human support

Merger due diligence processes can be time-consuming and will usually benefit from specialist legal, HR, and merger consultancy input. My study found that written toolkits alone aren’t enough. Specialist, independent support, who can reassure Boards, can add confidence to decision-making processes.

A risk-averse mindset effectively ends some merger considerations before they start. It’s easy to focus on fears of change and associated risks. But, for many charities, an assessment of the risks of no change, of continuing on with struggling finances, low beneficiary impact, and lack of internal resources, can realise even greater risks. Making use of opportune moments, developing a more visionary mindset, and using expert resources, can provide a more balanced comparison between the real risks of merging with the risks of staggering on with the status quo.

About the author:

Steve Chu, an experienced charity leader and non-executive director was previously Chief Executive at Age UK Sheffield. He is now an Eastside People consultant and freelance charity consultant.

For more information, or to receive a full copy of the dissertation, please visit www.stevechu.co.uk.

Too often, charity leaders can be fixated on the survival of their entity, over and above beneficiary outcomes.

Steve Chu, Eastside People Consultant

Get in Touch

Contact us to find out how our team of charity, social enterprise & not-for-profit consultants and recruiters can help your organisation.

Call, send an email or complete our simple contact form.

Phone: +44 (0) 203 821 6174
Email: [email protected]